Groom for Josie

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Smart Plot with Exasperating Leads
A classic tale of a mail-order groom who was, in fact, entirely un-ordered. Our fiercely independent heroine, Josie, has sworn off marriage, but her meddling brother decides she needs a husband anyway and places an ad. Enter Arlen: a weary sheriff looking to trade gunfights for domesticity. He arrives only to find Josie has absolutely no idea he was summoned. Naturally, instead of doing the sensible thing and leaving, he stays—smugly convinced he can win her over because he fancies the "fire in her eyes."
Frankly, Arlen’s arrogance is exhausting. He is so utterly sure of his own charms that one suffers a profound urge to bring him to his knees just to humble him. Josie, meanwhile, is trapped in that frustrating trope of the capable woman who somehow cannot see her own worth, convinced men only want her for her acreage.
Arlen attempts to court her by making himself useful and loudly appreciating the womanly figure hiding beneath her men's clothing. The plot thickens when a predatory lawyer tries to buy Josie’s land, foolishly approaching Arlen first—a blunder that rightfully sends Josie’s guard right back up. The pair are forced to put their romantic friction aside to unravel the lawyer's scheme, culminating in a high-stakes, gunpoint-wedding climax that delivers genuine tension.
While the plot is smartly constructed, the execution stumbles on the execution of the leads. A dash more character development could have transformed these exasperating archetypes into people we actually want to root for.